andrea dworkin
With the passing of Andrea Dworkin, I want to write some reflections on this much-maligned person.
The first time I read her name, it was in a trashy independent comic strip, called "Spacemoose". In the strip, she was made out to be like Jabba the Hutt, and attacks a pizza delivery man.
Reading about her life, it looks like she suffered a lot from violence at the hands of men. I have met some people who have been victims of violence (of various kinds) and who end up becoming hateful, which may have been the case for this person, I don't know. Initially, I didn't think there is anything wrong with starting some kind of women-only lesbian community. After all, there is a gay village here in Montreal, which serves a large segment of society. It is a thriving community and is an important part of the Montreal landscape, not to mention producing the biggest parade in Montreal. There is nothing wrong with ghettoization, in my opinion, if it is done by choice.
But then again, if one makes a comparison with race, then the idea of a women-only society does seem mysandric. After all, when Malcolm X wanted to form a black-only state in the USA, he was rightly criticized for this view. A number of Israeli zionists like Meir Kahane have advocated similar racist views. Separate but equal usually does not mean equal at all.
I agree with Dworkin on the idea that casual sex is generally a bad thing in that it often demeans people - both men and women. Pornography should be classified as hate literature if it is violent. I think that depictions of rape and bondage are illegal, as they should be.
Dworkin was a radical. And although there is nothing wrong with being radical per se, it seems to me that she lost sight of the humanist values that mark the lives of such activists as Gloria Steinem and Erica Jong (I bought and read "Fear of Flying" as a teenager because it had a sexy cover). It seems like the most noble proponents of feminism, civil rights, and the gay rights movement were intending to make all of society a better place, and to speak to our ideals, rather than our fears or animosities.